Vraag die bij mij en mn broer opgekomen was: Zijn tokens kaarten? Ze zijn namelijk alleen maar representaties.
Scenario:
Mijn broer en zijn vriend speelden tegen mij en mijn jongere broer. Zij hadden een hoop tokens, laten we het op snake houden in dit geval.
Mijn broertje speelt runed halo en noemt zijn kaart: "Snake". Zo heten de tokens namelijk. Is dit een geldige zet of niet, aangezien de Halo stelt "Name a card"?
Kaarten en tokens
Moderator: Admins & Moderators
Kaarten en tokens
By the time you finish reading this, you might realise that you have just wasted 2 to 5 seconds of your life.
- pi
- Archmage
- Berichten: 9184
- Lid geworden op: ma apr 01, 2002 11:00 am
- Locatie: Amsterdam
- Contacteer:
Re: Kaarten en tokens
Volgens mij kan het, maar weet niet welke regels dat precies zeggen.
Je kunt een bijdrage doen aan de kosten van dit forum via deze link.
- Donnie Darko
- Wizard
- Berichten: 615
- Lid geworden op: zo okt 04, 2009 6:57 pm
- Locatie: Driebergen
Re: Kaarten en tokens
Rulings op de gatherer:
--------------------------------------
1-5-2008 Runed Halo gives you protection from each object with the chosen name, whether it's a card, a token, or a copy of a spell. It doesn't matter what game zone that object is in.
1-5-2008 You can still be attacked by creatures with the chosen name.
1-5-2008 You'll have protection from the name, not from the word. For example, if you choose the name Forest, you'll have protection from anything named "Forest" -- but you won't have protection from Forests. An animated Sapseep Forest, for example, could deal damage to you even though its subtype is Forest.
1-5-2008 If you want to name a split card, you must name both halves of the card. You'll have protection from each half.
1-5-2008 You can't choose [nothing] as a name. Face-down creatures have no name, so Runed Halo can't give you protection from them.
1-5-2008 You must choose the name of a card, not the name of a token. For example, you can't choose "Saproling" or "Voja." However, if a token happens to have the same name as a card (such as "Shapeshifter" or "Goldmeadow Harrier"), you can choose it.
1-5-2008 You may choose either one of a flip card's names. You'll have protection only from the appropriate version. For example, if you choose Nighteyes the Desecrator, you won't have protection from Nezumi Graverobber.
--------------------------------------
Na de eerste rule zou ik zeggen: ja, dat kan. Maar ik denk dat de één na laatste ruling het verpest voor je broertje...
--------------------------------------
1-5-2008 Runed Halo gives you protection from each object with the chosen name, whether it's a card, a token, or a copy of a spell. It doesn't matter what game zone that object is in.
1-5-2008 You can still be attacked by creatures with the chosen name.
1-5-2008 You'll have protection from the name, not from the word. For example, if you choose the name Forest, you'll have protection from anything named "Forest" -- but you won't have protection from Forests. An animated Sapseep Forest, for example, could deal damage to you even though its subtype is Forest.
1-5-2008 If you want to name a split card, you must name both halves of the card. You'll have protection from each half.
1-5-2008 You can't choose [nothing] as a name. Face-down creatures have no name, so Runed Halo can't give you protection from them.
1-5-2008 You must choose the name of a card, not the name of a token. For example, you can't choose "Saproling" or "Voja." However, if a token happens to have the same name as a card (such as "Shapeshifter" or "Goldmeadow Harrier"), you can choose it.
1-5-2008 You may choose either one of a flip card's names. You'll have protection only from the appropriate version. For example, if you choose Nighteyes the Desecrator, you won't have protection from Nezumi Graverobber.
--------------------------------------
Na de eerste rule zou ik zeggen: ja, dat kan. Maar ik denk dat de één na laatste ruling het verpest voor je broertje...
Work is the curse of the drinking class
Re: Kaarten en tokens
Nee, helaas een token is geen kaart.
Wat die rulings eigenlijk zeggen, is dat als je eenmaal een geldige kaartnaam gezegd hebt, de ability ook op gaat voor tokens die een kopietje zijn van die kaart bijvoorbeeld.
CR 108.2. When a rule or text on a card refers to a “card,” it means only a Magic card. This includes both traditional Magic cards, which measure approximately 2.5 inches (6.3 cm) by 3.5 inches (8.8 cm) and have a “Deckmaster” back, and nontraditional Magic cards, which are oversized and have different backs. Tokens aren’t considered cards—even a card that represents a token isn’t considered a card for rules purposes.
Wat die rulings eigenlijk zeggen, is dat als je eenmaal een geldige kaartnaam gezegd hebt, de ability ook op gaat voor tokens die een kopietje zijn van die kaart bijvoorbeeld.
Iron Maiden's gonna get you
Scream for mercy // He laughs as he's watching you bleed // Killer behind you // His blood lust defies all his needs // Look out I'm coming for you!
Scream for mercy // He laughs as he's watching you bleed // Killer behind you // His blood lust defies all his needs // Look out I'm coming for you!